Sharuɗɗan Lafiya na Rauni na Rauni don Ƙarƙashin Ciwon Baya a El Paso, TX
Ƙananan ciwon baya yana wakiltar ɗaya daga cikin gunaguni na yau da kullum a cikin saitunan kiwon lafiya. Duk da yake raunuka daban-daban da yanayin da ke hade da musculoskeletal da tsarin juyayi na iya haifar da ƙananan ciwon baya, yawancin masu sana'a na kiwon lafiya sun yi imanin cewa raunin aiki na iya samun haɗin gwiwa mai yawa zuwa ƙananan ciwon baya. Misali, matsayi mara kyau da maimaita motsi na iya haifar da raunin da ya shafi aiki. A wasu lokuta, haɗarin muhalli a wurin aiki na iya haifar da raunin aiki. A kowane hali, bincikar tushen rashin ciwon baya na majiyyaci don tantance daidai wanne zai zama mafi kyawun hanyar magani don dawo da asalin lafiyar mutum da lafiyar gabaɗaya yana da ƙalubale.
Da farko dai, samun likitocin da suka dace don takamaiman tushen ku na ƙananan ciwon baya yana da mahimmanci don samun sauƙi daga alamun ku. Yawancin ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun aiki, gami da likitocin chiropractic ko chiropractors. A sakamakon haka, an kafa jagororin jiyya na raunin aiki da yawa don sarrafa ƙananan ciwon baya a cikin saitunan kiwon lafiya. Maganin chiropractic mayar da hankali kan bincike, magani, da kuma hana cututtuka daban-daban da yanayi, irin su LBP, da ke hade da musculoskeletal da tsarin juyayi. Ta hanyar gyaran gyare-gyare a hankali na kashin baya, kulawar chiropractic zai iya taimakawa wajen inganta bayyanar cututtuka na ƙananan ciwon baya, a tsakanin sauran alamun. Manufar labarin mai zuwa shine don tattauna jagororin kiwon lafiya na sana'a don kula da ƙananan ciwon baya.
Sharuɗɗan Lafiya na Sana'a don Gudanar da Ƙarƙashin Ciwon Baya: Kwatancen Ƙasashen Duniya
Abstract
- Bayan Fage: Babban nauyin zamantakewar tattalin arziki na ƙananan ciwon baya yana jaddada buƙatar sarrafa wannan matsala, musamman a cikin yanayin aiki yadda ya kamata. Don magance wannan, an fitar da jagororin sana'a a ƙasashe daban-daban.
- Neman: Don kwatanta jagororin ƙasashen duniya da aka samo don sarrafa ƙananan ciwon baya a cikin tsarin kula da lafiya na sana'a.
- Hanyar: An kwatanta jagororin game da ka'idodin ingancin da aka yarda da su gabaɗaya ta amfani da kayan aikin AGREE kuma an taƙaita game da kwamitin jagora, gabatarwa, ƙungiyar da aka yi niyya, da shawarwarin ƙima da gudanarwa (wato, shawara, komawa dabarun aiki, da magani).
- Sakamako da Karshe: Sakamakon ya nuna cewa jagororin sun cika ka'idojin inganci daban-daban. Matsalolin gama gari sun shafi rashin ingantaccen bita na waje a cikin tsarin ci gaba, rashin kulawa ga shingen ƙungiyoyi da abubuwan farashi, da rashin cikakken bayani kan gwargwadon yadda masu gyara da masu haɓaka suka kasance masu zaman kansu. Akwai yarjejeniya ta gaba ɗaya akan batutuwa masu yawa na asali don kula da lafiyar sana'a na ciwon baya. Shawarwari na kimantawa sun haɗa da tantancewar ganowa, bincikar tutoci masu ja da matsalolin jijiya, da gano yuwuwar matsalolin zamantakewa da wuraren aiki don murmurewa. Sharuɗɗa kuma sun yarda da shawara cewa ƙananan ciwon baya shine yanayin da ya dace da kai da kuma cewa zama a wurin aiki ko kuma da wuri (a hankali) komawa aiki, idan ya cancanta tare da gyare-gyaren ayyuka, ya kamata a karfafa da goyon baya.
Dr. Alex Jimenez's Insight
Ƙananan ciwon baya yana daya daga cikin batutuwan kiwon lafiya da suka fi dacewa da aka bi da su a ofisoshin chiropractic. Kodayake labarin da ke gaba ya kwatanta ƙananan ciwon baya a matsayin yanayin iyakance kansa, dalilin LBP na mutum kuma zai iya haifar da ciwo mai raɗaɗi da ciwo mai tsanani da rashin jin daɗi na hagu ba tare da magani ba. Yana da mahimmanci ga mutumin da ke da alamun ƙananan ciwon baya don neman magani mai kyau tare da chiropractor don bincikar lafiya da kyau da kuma kula da al'amuran kiwon lafiyar su da kuma hana su dawowa a nan gaba. Marasa lafiya da ke fama da ƙananan ciwon baya fiye da watanni 3 sun kasance ƙasa da kashi 3 na iya komawa aiki. Kulawa na chiropractic wani zaɓi ne mai aminci da inganci wanda zai iya taimakawa wajen mayar da ainihin aikin kashin baya. Bugu da ƙari kuma, likita na chiropractic, ko chiropractor, na iya ba da gyare-gyaren salon rayuwa, irin su shawarwarin abinci mai gina jiki da dacewa, don hanzarta aikin dawo da marasa lafiya. Waraka ta hanyar motsi yana da mahimmanci don dawo da LBP.
Ƙananan ciwon baya (LBP) ɗaya ne daga cikin ƙasashen masana'antu mafi yawan matsalolin kiwon lafiya. Duk da yanayinsa mai kyau da yanayin sauti, LBP yana da alaƙa da rashin ƙarfi, asarar yawan aiki saboda izinin rashin lafiya, da tsadar al'umma.[1]
Saboda wannan tasirin, akwai buƙatu a fili don ingantattun dabarun gudanarwa bisa ga shaidar kimiyya da aka samo daga nazarin ingancin ingantacciyar hanya. Yawancin lokaci, waɗannan gwaje-gwajen da aka sarrafa bazuwar (RCTs) ne akan tasiri na hanyoyin warkewa, nazarin bincike, ko nazarin abubuwan da za a iya gani a kan abubuwan haɗari ko illa. Shaidar kimiyya, wanda aka taƙaita a cikin sake dubawa na tsari da ƙididdigar meta, yana ba da ingantaccen tushe don jagororin sarrafa LBP. A cikin takarda da ta gabata, Koes et al. idan aka kwatanta jagororin asibiti daban-daban don sarrafa LBP da aka yi niyya ga ƙwararrun kiwon lafiya na farko, suna nuna babban abin gama gari.[2]
Matsalolin kiwon lafiya na sana'a sun bambanta. Gudanarwa ya fi mayar da hankali kan ba da shawara ga ma'aikaci tare da LBP da kuma magance matsalolin taimaka musu su ci gaba da aiki ko komawa aiki (RTW) bayan jerin marasa lafiya. Duk da haka, LBP kuma wani muhimmin al'amari ne a cikin kula da lafiyar sana'a saboda rashin iya aiki na haɗin gwiwa, asarar yawan aiki, da kuma rashin lafiya. Jagorori da yawa, ko sassan jagororin, an buga yanzu suna ma'amala da takamaiman batutuwan gudanarwa a cikin yanayin kula da lafiya na sana'a. Tun da shaida ta kasa da kasa, za a sa ran cewa shawarwarin jagororin sana'a daban-daban na LBP zasu kasance fiye ko žasa. Duk da haka, ba a bayyana ko jagororin sun cika ka'idojin inganci da aka yarda da su a halin yanzu ba.
Wannan takarda tana kimanta jagororin sana'a da ake da su akan sarrafa LBP kuma tana kwatanta kima da shawarwarin gudanarwa.
Babban Saƙonni
- A cikin ƙasashe daban-daban, ana ba da jagororin kiwon lafiya na sana'a don inganta kula da ƙananan ciwon baya a cikin yanayin aiki.
- Matsalolin gama gari na waɗannan jagororin sun shafi rashin ingantaccen bita na waje a cikin tsarin haɓakawa, rashin kulawa ga shingen ƙungiyoyi da abubuwan farashi, da ƙarancin bayanai kan 'yancin kai na masu gyara da masu haɓakawa.
- Gabaɗaya, shawarwarin kima a cikin jagororin sun ƙunshi nau'ikan bincike, yin gwajin jajayen tutoci da matsalolin jijiya, da gano yuwuwar matsalolin zamantakewa da wuraren aiki don murmurewa.
- Akwai yarjejeniya ta gaba ɗaya game da shawara cewa ƙananan ciwon baya shine yanayin da ya dace da kai da kuma cewa sauran aiki a wurin aiki ko kuma da wuri (a hankali) komawa aiki, idan ya cancanta tare da ayyukan da aka gyara, ya kamata a karfafa da goyon baya.
Hanyar
An dawo da jagororin kan kula da lafiyar sana'a na LBP daga fayilolin sirri na marubuta. An duba sake dawowa ta hanyar bincike na Medline ta amfani da maƙallan ƙananan ciwon baya, jagorori, da sana'a har zuwa Oktoba 2001, da sadarwar sirri tare da masana a cikin filin. Manufofin dole ne su cika ka'idojin haɗawa masu zuwa:
- Sharuɗɗan da ke nufin sarrafa ma'aikata tare da LBP (a cikin saitunan kiwon lafiya na sana'a ko magance matsalolin sana'a) ko sassa daban-daban na manufofin da suka shafi waɗannan batutuwa.
- Ana samun jagororin cikin Ingilishi ko Yaren mutanen Holland (ko kuma an fassara su cikin waɗannan harsuna).
Sharuɗɗan keɓancewa sune:
- Sharuɗɗa akan rigakafin farko (wato, rigakafi kafin fara bayyanar cututtuka) na LBP masu aiki (misali, umarnin ɗagawa ga ma'aikata).
- Jagororin asibiti don gudanar da LBP a cikin kulawa na farko.[2]
An kimanta ingancin jagororin da aka haɗa ta amfani da kayan aikin AGREE, kayan aikin gama gari da aka tsara da farko don taimakawa masu haɓakawa da masu amfani da su tantance ingancin tsarin jagororin aikin asibiti.[3]
Kayan aikin AGREE yana ba da tsari don tantance ingancin akan abubuwa 24 (tebur 1), kowannensu da aka ƙididdige shi akan ma'auni huɗu. Ana samun cikakken aikin aiki akan www.agreecollaboration.org.
Masu bita guda biyu (BS da HH) sun ƙididdige ingancin jagororin da kansu sannan su hadu don tattauna rashin jituwa da kuma cimma matsaya kan ƙimar. Lokacin da suka kasa yarda, mai bita na uku (MvT) ya daidaita sauran bambance-bambancen kuma ya yanke shawara akan ƙimar. Don sauƙaƙe bincike a cikin wannan bita, an canza ƙididdiga zuwa ma'auni daban-daban na ko kowane abu mai inganci ya kasance ko bai cika ba.
An taƙaita shawarwarin kima kuma idan aka kwatanta da shawarwari akan shawarwari, jiyya, da komawa dabarun aiki. An kara kwatanta jagororin da aka zaɓa kuma an kai su game da kwamitin jagora, gabatar da tsarin, ƙungiyar da aka yi niyya, da kuma gwargwadon shawarwarin da aka dogara akan shaidar kimiyya. Duk waɗannan bayanan an ciro su kai tsaye daga jagororin da aka buga.
Tasirin Siyasa
- Gudanar da ƙananan ciwon baya a cikin kula da lafiyar sana'a ya kamata ya bi ka'idodin tushen shaida.
- Sharuɗɗan sana'a na gaba don kula da ƙananan ciwon baya da sabuntawa na waɗannan jagororin ya kamata suyi la'akari da ma'auni don ingantaccen ci gaba, aiwatarwa, da kuma kimanta hanyoyin da aka ba da shawara ta hanyar haɗin gwiwar AGREE.
results
Zaɓin Nazari
Bincikenmu ya samo jagororin goma, amma an cire hudu saboda sun yi hulɗa da gudanarwa na LBP a cikin kulawa na farko, [15] an yi nufin jagorancin ma'aikatan da aka jera marasa lafiya gabaɗaya (ba musamman LBP ba), [16] an yi niyya don rigakafin farko na LBP a wurin aiki, [17] ko ba a samuwa a cikin Ingilishi ko Yaren mutanen Holland.[18] Zaɓin ƙarshe, don haka, ya ƙunshi jagororin guda shida masu zuwa, waɗanda aka jera ta kwanan wata:
(1) Kanada (Quebec). Hanyar kimiyya don kimantawa da kula da cututtuka na kashin baya da ke da alaka da aiki. A monograph ga likitoci. Rahoton Ƙungiyar Task Force na Quebec akan Cututtukan Spinal. Quebec Kanada (1987).[4]
(2) Australia (Victoria). Sharuɗɗa don kula da ma'aikata tare da ƙananan ƙananan ciwon baya. Hukumar Kula da Ayyukan Aikin Victoria, Ostiraliya (1996).[5] (Wannan sigar jagororin da South Australian WorkCover Corporation suka haɓaka a cikin Oktoba 1993.)
(3) Amurka. Jagororin Ayyukan Magungunan Ma'aikata. Kwalejin Amirka na Ma'aikata da Magungunan Muhalli. Amurka (1997).[6]
(4) New Zealand
(a) Aiki da aiki! Sarrafa m ƙananan ciwon baya a wurin aiki. Kamfanin Diyya na Hatsari da Kwamitin Lafiya na Kasa. New Zealand (2000).[7]
(b) Jagoran haƙuri don kula da ƙananan ciwon baya. Kamfanin Diyya na Hatsari da Kwamitin Lafiya na Kasa. New Zealand (1998).[8]
(c) Yi la'akari da tutoci masu launin rawaya na psychosocial a cikin ƙananan ƙananan ciwon baya. Kamfanin Diyya na Hatsari da Kwamitin Lafiya na Kasa. New Zealand (1997).[9]
(5) Netherlands. Jagoran Yaren mutanen Holland don kula da likitocin sana'a na ma'aikata tare da ƙananan ciwon baya. Ƙungiyar Magungunan Ma'aikata ta Holland (NVAB). Netherlands (1999).[10]
(6) UK
(a) Jagororin kiwon lafiya na sana'a don sarrafa ƙananan ciwon baya a manyan shawarwarin aiki. Makarantar Magungunan Ma'aikata. Birtaniya (2000).[11]
(b) Jagororin kiwon lafiya na sana'a don sarrafa ƙananan ciwon baya a takardar aiki don masu aiki. Makarantar Magungunan Ma'aikata. Birtaniya (2000).[12]
(c) Jagororin kiwon lafiya na sana'a don sarrafa ƙananan ciwon baya a nazarin shaidar aikin. Makarantar Magungunan Ma'aikata. Birtaniya (2000).[13]
(d) Littafin Baya, Ofishin Kayan Aiki. Birtaniya (1996).[14]
Ba za a iya kimanta jagororin biyu (4 da 6) ba daban-daban daga ƙarin takaddun da suke magana akai (4bc, 6bd), don haka waɗannan takaddun an haɗa su cikin bita.
Kima na Ingancin Jagororin
Da farko, an yi yarjejeniya tsakanin masu bitar biyu game da 106 (77%) na ƙimar abubuwa 138. Bayan tarurrukan biyu, an cimma matsaya akan dukkan abubuwa in ban da abubuwa hudu, wadanda suka bukaci yanke hukunci daga mai nazari na uku. Table 1 yana gabatar da ƙimar ƙarshe.
Dukkan jagororin da aka haɗa sun gabatar da zaɓuɓɓuka daban-daban don sarrafa LBP a cikin lafiyar sana'a. A cikin biyar daga cikin manufofin shida, an bayyana maƙasudin tsarin gaba ɗaya a sarari, [46, 1014] an bayyana masu amfani da tsarin a sarari, [514] an haɗa mahimman shawarwarin da za a iya ganewa cikin sauƙi, [4, 614] ko nazari mai mahimmanci. an gabatar da ma'auni don sa ido da dalilai na tantancewa.[49, 1114].
Sakamakon kimar AGREE ya nuna cewa babu ɗaya daga cikin ƙa'idodin da ya ba da isasshiyar kulawa ga yuwuwar shingen ƙungiyoyi da abubuwan farashi wajen aiwatar da shawarwarin. Har ila yau, ba a sani ba ga duk ƙa'idodin da aka haɗa ko sun kasance masu zaman kansu a edita ko a'a ba tare da hukumar ba da kudade ba kuma ko akwai rikice-rikice na sha'awa ga mambobin kwamitocin ci gaban jagora. Bugu da ƙari, babu tabbas ga duk ƙa'idodin ko ƙwararrun sun sake nazarin manufofin a waje kafin bugawa. Jagoran Burtaniya kawai ya bayyana a sarari hanyar da aka yi amfani da ita don tsara shawarwari da kuma tanadar don sabunta tsarin.[11]
Haɓaka Sharuɗɗa
Tebur na 2 yana gabatar da bayanan baya akan tsarin ci gaba na jagororin.
Masu amfani da aka yi niyya don jagororin sun kasance likitoci da sauran masu ba da lafiya a fagen kiwon lafiya na sana'a. An kuma ba da umarni da yawa manufofi don sanar da ma'aikata, ma'aikata [68, 11, 14], ko membobin kungiyoyi masu sha'awar lafiyar sana'a.[4] Jagoran Yaren mutanen Holland an yi niyya ne kawai ga likitan lafiyar sana'a.[10]
Kwamitocin jagororin da ke da alhakin haɓaka jagororin gabaɗaya sun kasance nau'i-nau'i iri-iri, gami da fannonin ilimi kamar su annoba, ergonomics, physiotherapy, aikin gama-gari, likitancin sana'a, likitancin sana'a, likitocin kashi, da wakilan ƙungiyoyin ma'aikata da ƙungiyoyin kasuwanci. Wakilan Chiropractic da osteopathic sun kasance a cikin kwamitin jagora na jagororin New Zealand.[79] Rundunar aikin Quebec (Kanada) ta kuma haɗa da wakilan likitancin gyarawa, rheumatology, tattalin arziki na kiwon lafiya, doka, neurosurgery, injiniyan biomechanical, da kimiyyar ɗakin karatu. Sabanin haka, kwamitin jagora na jagorar Dutch ya ƙunshi likitocin sana'a kawai.[10]
An ba da jagororin a matsayin takarda dabam, [4, 5, 10] a matsayin babi a cikin littafi, [6] ko kuma a matsayin wasu takardu masu alaƙa.[79, 1114].
Birtaniya, [13] Amurka, [6] da Kanada [4] jagororin sun ba da bayani game da dabarun binciken da aka yi amfani da su don gano wallafe-wallafen da suka dace da kuma auna shaidar. A gefe guda, ƙa'idodin Dutch[10] da jagororin Ostiraliya [5] sun goyi bayan shawarwarin su ta hanyar nassoshi kawai. Jagororin New Zealand ba su nuna alaƙa kai tsaye tsakanin shawarwari da damuwa [79]. An tura mai karatu zuwa wasu wallafe-wallafen don bayanin asali.
Yawan Jama'a da Shawarwari na Bincike
Kodayake duk jagororin sun mayar da hankali ga ma'aikata tare da LBP, sau da yawa ba a sani ba ko sun yi maganin LBP mai tsanani ko na kullum ko duka biyu. LBP mai tsanani da na yau da kullum ba a bayyana su ba, kuma an ba da maki yanke (misali, <3 watanni). Yawancin lokaci ba a sani ba ko waɗannan suna nufin farkon alamun ko rashin aiki. Duk da haka, ka'idar Kanada ta gabatar da tsarin rarrabawa (mai tsanani / subacute / na kullum) bisa ga rarraba da'awar cututtuka na kashin baya ta lokaci tun lokacin da ba a aiki.[4]
Duk jagororin sun bambanta takamammen ƙayyadaddun LBP. Musamman LBP ya shafi yiwuwar mummunan yanayin alamar ja kamar karaya, ciwace-ciwacen ƙwayoyi, ko cututtuka, da ka'idodin Dutch da na Birtaniya kuma sun bambanta ciwon radicular ko ciwon tushen jijiya.[1013] Dukkanin hanyoyin sun kasance daidai a cikin shawarwarin su don ɗaukar tarihin asibiti da kuma gudanar da gwajin jiki, ciki har da gwajin jini. A lokuta da ake zargin takamaiman cututtukan cututtuka (jajayen tutoci), yawancin jagororin sun ba da shawarar gwajin x-ray. Bugu da ƙari, New Zealand da jagororin Amurka sun kuma ba da shawarar gwajin x-ray lokacin da bayyanar cututtuka ba su inganta ba bayan makonni hudu. mai haƙuri tare da LBP (bambanta daga kowane alamun asibiti).[6]
Yawancin jagororin sunyi la'akari da abubuwan zamantakewa a matsayin tutocin rawaya a matsayin cikas ga farfadowa da masu samar da lafiya ya kamata su magance. New Zealand [9] da jagororin Burtaniya [11, 12] a bayyane abubuwan da aka jera su da tambayoyin da aka ba da shawarar don gano waɗancan tutocin launin rawaya na psychosocial.
Dukkan jagororin sun yi magana game da mahimmancin tarihin asibiti wanda ke gano abubuwan da ke tattare da yanayin aiki na jiki da na psychosocial da suka dace da LBP, gami da buƙatun jiki na aiki (harɓar hannu, ɗagawa, lanƙwasa, karkatarwa, da fallasa ga rawar jiki gaba ɗaya), hatsarori ko raunin da ya faru, da matsalolin da aka gane. a komawa aiki ko dangantaka a wurin aiki. Jagororin Dutch da na Kanada sun ƙunshi shawarwari don gudanar da binciken wurin aiki[10] ko kimanta ƙwarewar sana'a idan ya cancanta.[4]
Takaitacciyar Shawarwari don Ƙimar LBP
- Ƙididdigar bincike (wanda ba takamaiman LBP ba, ciwo na radicular, takamaiman LBP).
- Banda jajayen tutoci da duban jijiya.
- Gano abubuwan da suka shafi tunanin mutum da kuma abubuwan da za su iya kawo cikas ga farfadowa.
- Gano abubuwan wurin aiki (na jiki da na psychosocial) waɗanda zasu iya alaƙa da matsalar LBP kuma komawa aiki.
- Gwajin X-ray an iyakance shi ga wasu lokuta da ake zargi da cutar ta musamman.
Shawarwari Game da Bayani da Nasiha, Jiyya, da Komawa Dabarun Aiki
Yawancin jagororin sun ba da shawarar ƙarfafa ma'aikaci da kuma samar da bayanai game da yanayin ƙayyadaddun kai na LBP da kyakkyawan hasashen. An sha ba da shawarar ƙarfafa komawa ga ayyukan yau da kullun gabaɗaya gwargwadon yiwuwa.
A cikin layi tare da shawarwarin don komawa aiki na yau da kullum, duk jagororin kuma sun jaddada mahimmancin komawa aiki da sauri kamar yadda zai yiwu, koda kuwa har yanzu akwai wasu LBP kuma, idan ya cancanta, farawa tare da gyare-gyaren ayyuka a cikin mafi tsanani lokuta. Za a iya ƙara ayyukan aiki a hankali (awanni da ayyuka) har sai an kai ga koma baya ga aiki. Jagororin Amurka da Dutch sun ba da cikakken jadawalin lokaci don dawowa aiki. Hanyar Dutch ta ba da shawarar komawa aiki a cikin makonni biyu tare da daidaita ayyukan aiki idan ya cancanta.[10] Har ila yau, tsarin Yaren mutanen Holland ya jaddada mahimmancin kulawar lokaci-lokaci game da komawa aiki.[10] Jagoran Amurka ya ba da shawarar kowane ƙoƙari na kula da majiyyaci a mafi girman matakan aiki, gami da ayyukan aiki; An ba da maƙasudin tsawon lokacin nakasa dangane da komawa aiki a matsayin kwanakin 02 tare da gyare-gyaren ayyuka da kwanakin 714 idan ba a yi amfani da ayyukan da aka gyara ba.[6] Ya bambanta da sauran, ka'idar Kanada ta ba da shawarar komawa aiki kawai lokacin da alamun cututtuka da ƙuntatawa na aiki suka inganta.[4]
Zaɓuɓɓukan jiyya da aka fi ba da shawarar akai-akai a cikin duk jagororin da aka haɗa sune: magani don jin zafi, [5, 7, 8] shirye-shiryen motsa jiki na ci gaba a hankali, [6, 10] da gyare-gyare na multidisciplinary.[1013] Jagoran Amurka ya ba da shawarar turawa cikin makonni biyu zuwa shirin motsa jiki wanda ya ƙunshi motsa jiki na motsa jiki, motsa jiki na motsa jiki don tsokoki, da adadin motsa jiki.[6] Jagoran Yaren mutanen Holland ya ba da shawarar cewa idan babu ci gaba a cikin makonni biyu na rashin aiki, ya kamata a mayar da ma'aikata zuwa tsarin aiki mai daraja (yawan motsa jiki a hankali) kuma, idan ba a inganta ta makonni hudu ba, zuwa shirin gyaran gyare-gyare na multidisciplinary.[10] ] Jagoran Burtaniya ya ba da shawarar cewa ma'aikatan da ke da wahalar komawa ayyukan sana'a na yau da kullun da makonni 412 ya kamata a mayar da su zuwa wani shiri na farfadowa. Wannan shirin gyarawa ya kamata ya haɗa da ilimi, tabbatarwa da shawara, ci gaba da motsa jiki mai karfi da shirin motsa jiki, da kuma kula da ciwo bisa ga ka'idodin hali; ya kamata a saka shi a cikin wani wuri na sana'a kuma a kai tsaye zuwa ga komawa zuwa aiki. akan shaidar kimiyya.
Takaitacciyar Shawarwari Game da Bayani, Shawara, Komawa Ma'aunin Aiki, da Jiyya a Ma'aikata tare da LBP
- Tabbatar da ma'aikaci kuma ya ba da isassun bayanai game da yanayin ƙayyadaddun kai na LBP da kyakkyawan hasashe.
- Shawarci ma'aikaci don ci gaba da ayyukan yau da kullun ko komawa motsa jiki na yau da kullun da aiki da wuri-wuri, koda kuwa akwai sauran ciwo.
- Yawancin ma'aikata tare da LBP suna komawa zuwa fiye ko žasa ayyuka na yau da kullum da sauri. Yi la'akari da daidaitawa na wucin gadi na ayyukan aiki (awanni / ayyuka) kawai idan ya cancanta.
- Lokacin da ma'aikaci ya kasa komawa aiki a cikin makonni na 212 (akwai bambanci mai yawa a cikin ma'auni na lokaci a cikin jagororin daban-daban), mayar da su zuwa shirin motsa jiki na karuwa a hankali, ko gyaran gyare-gyare na multidisciplinary (ayyukan motsa jiki, ilimi, tabbatarwa, da kuma kula da jin zafi bin ka'idodin hali. ). Waɗannan shirye-shiryen gyarawa
ya kamata a sanya shi a cikin yanayin aiki.
tattaunawa
Gudanar da LBP a cikin yanayin kiwon lafiya na sana'a dole ne ya magance alakar da ke tsakanin ƙananan gunaguni da aiki da kuma samar da dabarun da ake nufi don dawowa aiki lafiya. Wannan bita ya kwatanta jagororin kiwon lafiyar sana'a daga ƙasashe daban-daban. Ba a cika lissafin manufofi a cikin Medline ba, don haka lokacin neman jagororin, dole ne mu dogara da farko ga fayilolin sirri da sadarwar sirri.
Halayen Inganci da Tsarin Ci gaba na Jagororin
Ƙimar da kayan aikin AGREE[3] ya nuna ya nuna wasu bambance-bambance a cikin ingancin jagororin da aka duba, wanda zai iya nuna wani ɓangare na bambancin kwanakin ci gaba da buga jagororin. Jagoran Kanada, alal misali, an buga shi a cikin 1987 da ƙa'idodin Australiya a cikin 1996.
Yawancin kuskuren gama gari da suka danganci tsarin ci gaba na jagororin an nuna su ta hanyar kima ta kayan aikin AGREE. Da fari dai, yana da mahimmanci a bayyana ko jagorar ta kasance mai zaman kanta ta edita daga ƙungiyar masu ba da kuɗi, da kuma ko akwai rikice-rikice na sha'awa ga membobin kwamitin jagora. Babu ɗaya daga cikin ƙa'idodin da aka haɗa da ya ba da rahoton waɗannan batutuwa a sarari. Bugu da ari, rahoton binciken waje na jagorar ta kwararrun likitocin asibiti da hanyoyin kafin a buga su ma sun rasa duk jagororin da aka haɗa cikin wannan bita.
Sharuɗɗa da yawa sun ba da cikakkun bayanai game da yadda aka bincika wallafe-wallafen da suka dace da kuma fassara su zuwa shawarwari. ƙarfin jagororin ko shawarwarin su.
Sharuɗɗa sun dogara da shaidar kimiyya, waɗanda ke canzawa akan lokaci, kuma yana da ban mamaki cewa jagora guda ɗaya kawai aka bayar don sabuntawa nan gaba. zai zama sabuntawa na gaba ba yana nufin zai faru a zahiri ba). Wannan rashin rahoton na iya kasancewa gaskiya ga sauran ka'idojin AGREE waɗanda muka ƙididdige su mara kyau. Yin amfani da tsarin AGREE a matsayin jagora don haɓakawa da kuma bayar da rahoto na jagororin ya kamata ya taimaka wajen inganta ingantaccen jagororin gaba.
Ƙimar da Gudanar da LBP
Hanyoyin bincike da aka ba da shawarar a cikin jagororin kiwon lafiya na sana'a sun fi kama da shawarwarin jagororin asibiti, [2] kuma, a ma'ana, babban bambanci shine mahimmancin magance matsalolin sana'a. Hanyoyin da aka ruwaito don magance abubuwan wuraren aiki a cikin kima na LBP na kowane ma'aikaci ya shafi gano ayyuka masu wuyar gaske, abubuwan haɗari, da kuma cikas don komawa aiki ta tarihin sana'a. Babu shakka, waɗannan cikas don komawa aiki ba kawai sun shafi abubuwan nauyin jiki ba ne kawai, har ma suna aiki da matsalolin zamantakewar zamantakewa game da nauyi, haɗin gwiwa tare da abokan aiki, da yanayin zamantakewa a wurin aiki.[10] Nunawa ga tutoci masu launin rawaya masu alaƙa da aiki na iya taimakawa wajen gano waɗancan ma'aikatan da ke cikin haɗari don ciwo mai tsanani da nakasa.[1113]
Wata mahimmanci mai mahimmanci na jagororin shine cewa sun kasance daidai game da shawarwarin su don tabbatar da ma'aikaci tare da LBP, kuma don ƙarfafawa da goyan bayan komawa aiki har ma da wasu alamun ci gaba. Akwai yarjejeniya gaba ɗaya cewa yawancin ma'aikata ba dole ba ne su jira har sai sun sami cikakkiyar jin daɗi kafin su dawo bakin aiki. Lissafin zaɓuɓɓukan magani da jagororin Kanada da Ostiraliya suka bayar na iya nuna rashin shaida a wancan lokacin, [4, 5] barin masu amfani da jagororin don zaɓar wa kansu. Yana da, duk da haka, abin tambaya ko irin waɗannan lissafin suna ba da gudummawa ga ingantacciyar kulawa, kuma a ra'ayinmu shawarwarin jagororin ya kamata su kasance bisa ingantacciyar shaidar kimiyya.
Jagororin sana'a na Amurka, Dutch, da Burtaniya [6, 1013] sun ba da shawarar cewa jiyya mai aiki na multidisciplinary shine mafi kyawun sa baki don komawa aiki, kuma wannan yana da goyan bayan shaida mai ƙarfi daga RCTs.[19, 20] Duk da haka, ƙarin bincike yana har yanzu. da ake buƙata don gano mafi kyawun abun ciki da ƙarfin waɗannan fakitin jiyya.[13, 21]
Duk da wasu shaidun gudummawar abubuwan da ke cikin wurin aiki a cikin aetiology na LBP, [22] hanyoyin da aka tsara don daidaitawa wurin aiki sun rasa, kuma ba a ba da su azaman shawarwari a cikin jagororin ba. Wataƙila wannan yana wakiltar rashin amincewa da shaida kan tasirin tasirin abubuwan wuraren aiki gabaɗaya, wahalar fassara zuwa jagora mai amfani, ko kuma saboda waɗannan batutuwan sun ruɗe da dokokin gida (wanda aka nuna a cikin jagororin Burtaniya[11]). Yana iya zama cewa shiga tsakani ergonomics, wanda ke ba da shawarwari tare da ma'aikaci, ma'aikaci, da ergonomist, zai zama mai amfani da komawa ga aikin sa baki. 23] an jaddada shi a cikin jagororin Dutch da UK, [24] amma ana buƙatar ƙarin kimantawa game da wannan tsarin da aiwatar da shi.
Haɓaka Jagororin gaba a cikin Kula da Lafiyar Sana'a
Manufar wannan bita shine don ba da taƙaitaccen bayani da ƙima mai mahimmanci na jagororin sana'a don gudanar da LBP. Mahimman ƙima na jagororin ana nufin taimakawa ci gaban gaba kai tsaye da sabunta sabbin jagororin. A cikin fage na tsarin jagora wanda har yanzu ya kunno kai muna ɗaukar duk abubuwan da suka gabata a matsayin abin yabawa; mun fahimci buƙatar jagorar asibiti, kuma mun yaba da cewa jagororin masu haɓakawa ba za su iya jira bincike don samar da duk hanyoyin da shaida da ake buƙata ba. Koyaya, akwai ɗaki don haɓakawa kuma jagororin gaba da sabuntawa yakamata suyi la'akari da ma'auni don ingantaccen haɓakawa, aiwatarwa, da kimanta jagororin kamar yadda haɗin gwiwar AGREE ya ba da shawara.
Aiwatar da ka'idodin ya wuce iyakar wannan bita, amma an lura cewa babu ɗaya daga cikin takaddun jagororin da ya bayyana dabarun aiwatarwa musamman, don haka ba a da tabbas ko menene aka cimma ƙungiyoyin da aka yi niyya, da kuma irin tasirin da ka iya haifarwa. . Wannan yana iya zama yanki mai fa'ida don ƙarin bincike.
Kasancewar waɗannan jagororin kiwon lafiya na sana'a sun nuna cewa ƙa'idodin kulawa na farko na LBP2 ana ɗaukar su bai dace ba ko kuma bai isa ba don kula da lafiyar sana'a. Akwai bayyananniyar fahimta a duniya cewa bukatun ma'aikacin da ke fama da ciwon baya yana da alaƙa da alaƙa da al'amuran sana'a iri-iri waɗanda ba a rufe su ta hanyar jagorar kulawa ta farko da aka saba kuma, saboda haka, aiki. Abin da ke fitowa shi ne, duk da kurakuran hanyoyin, yarjejeniya mai yawa ta bayyana akan yawancin dabarun kiwon lafiya na sana'a don kula da ma'aikaci tare da ciwon baya, wasu daga cikinsu suna da ƙwarewa da ƙalubalanci ra'ayoyin da aka yi a baya. Akwai yarjejeniya a kan ainihin saƙon cewa tsawaita asarar aiki na da lahani, kuma ya kamata a ƙarfafa da kuma sauƙaƙa dawowa aiki da wuri; babu buƙatar jira cikakken ƙudurin alamar. Kodayake dabarun da aka ba da shawarar sun bambanta da ɗan kaɗan, akwai yarjejeniya mai yawa akan ƙimar tabbataccen tabbaci da nasiha, samuwar (na ɗan lokaci) gyare-gyaren aiki, magance matsalolin wurin aiki (samun duk 'yan wasa a waje), da kuma gyara ga ma'aikatan da ke da wahalar komawa bakin aiki.
Godiya
Wannan binciken ya sami goyan bayan Hukumar Inshorar Kula da Lafiya ta Dutch (CVZ), ba da DPZ no. 169/0, Amstelveen, Netherlands. JB Staal a halin yanzu yana aiki a Sashen Nazarin Cututtuka, Jami'ar Maastricht, PO Box 616 6200 MD Maastricht, Netherlands. W van Mechelen kuma wani ɓangare ne na Cibiyar Bincike akan Ayyukan Jiki, Aiki da Lafiya, Jiki @ aiki TNO-VUmc.
A ƙarshe, bayyanar cututtuka na ƙananan ciwon baya shine daya daga cikin al'amuran kiwon lafiya na yau da kullum da ke hade da raunin aiki. Saboda haka, an kafa jagororin kiwon lafiyar sana'a da yawa don kula da ƙananan ciwon baya. Kulawar chiropractic, a tsakanin sauran hanyoyin magani, ana iya amfani da su don taimakawa mai haƙuri ya sami taimako daga LBP. Bugu da ƙari kuma, labarin da ke sama ya nuna aminci da tasiri na al'ada iri-iri da kuma madadin hanyoyin magance cututtuka a cikin ganewar asali, jiyya da kuma rigakafi da dama na ƙananan ciwon baya. Duk da haka, ana buƙatar ƙarin nazarin bincike don ƙayyade yadda ya dace na kowane hanyar magani. Bayanin da aka ambata daga Cibiyar Bayanan Kimiyyar Halittu ta Ƙasa (NCBI). Matsakaicin bayanin mu yana iyakance ga chiropractic da kuma raunin da ya faru da kashin baya. Don tattauna batun batun, don Allah jin daɗin tambayar Dr. Jimenez ko tuntuɓe mu a 915-850-0900 .
Dr. Alex Jimenez ne ya shirya shi
Ƙarin Maudu'i: Ciwon Baya
Bisa ga kididdigar, kimanin 80% na mutane za su fuskanci alamun ciwon baya a kalla sau ɗaya a duk rayuwarsu. Binciken baya koke ne na gama-gari wanda zai iya haifar da rauni da/ko yanayi iri-iri. Sau da yawa lokuta, lalacewar dabi'a na kashin baya tare da shekaru na iya haifar da ciwon baya. Harsiated fayafai faruwa a lokacin da taushi, gel-kamar cibiyar intervertebral disc ta tura ta cikin hawaye a kewaye da shi, waje zobe na guringuntsi, matsawa da kuma fusatar da jijiya tushen. Abubuwan da aka fi sani da diski suna faruwa tare da ƙananan baya, ko kashin baya na lumbar, amma kuma suna iya faruwa tare da kashin mahaifa, ko wuyansa. Ƙunƙarar jijiyoyi da aka samo a cikin ƙananan baya saboda rauni da / ko mummunan yanayin zai iya haifar da bayyanar cututtuka na sciatica.
MAFI MUHIMMAN BUDURWA: Maganin Ciwon Migraine
KARATUN BATUN: EXTRA EXTRA: El Paso, Tx | 'Yan wasa
Blank
References
2. Koes BW, van Tulder MW, Ostelo R, et al. Sharuɗɗa na asibiti don kula da ƙananan ciwon baya a cikin kulawa na farko: na duniya
kwatanta. Kashin baya 2001;26:2504-14.
3. Haɗin gwiwar AGREE. Ƙimar Bincike na Jagorori &
Kayan Aiki, www.agreecollaboration.org.
4. Spitzer WO, Leblanc FE, Dupuis M. Hanyar kimiyya zuwa ga
kima da kuma kula da cututtuka na kashin baya da ke da alaka da aiki. A monograph ga likitoci. Rahoton Ƙungiyar Task Force na Quebec akan Cututtukan Spinal. Kashin baya 1987; 12 (kayyade 7S): 1�59.
5. Hukumar Kula da Ayyukan Aikin Victoria. Sharuɗɗa don kula da ma'aikata tare da ƙananan ƙananan ciwon baya. Melbourne: Hukumar Kula da Ayyukan Aikin Victoria, 1996.
6. Harris JS. Jagororin aikin likitancin sana'a. Beverly, MA: OEM Press, 1997.
7. Kamfanin Diyya na Hatsari da Kwamitin Lafiya na Kasa. Aiki da aiki! Sarrafa m ƙananan ciwon baya a wurin aiki. Wellington, New Zealand, 2000.
8. Kamfanin Diyya na Hatsari da Kwamitin Lafiya na Kasa, Ma'aikatar Lafiya. Jagoran haƙuri don kula da ƙananan ciwon baya. Wellington, New Zealand, 1998.
9. Kendall, Linton SJ, Main CJ. Jagora don tantance alamun launin rawaya na psychosocial a cikin ƙananan ƙananan ciwon baya. Abubuwan haɗari don naƙasa na dogon lokaci da asarar aiki. Wellington, New Zealand, Gyaran Hatsari & Kamfanin Inshorar Ramuwa na New Zealand da Kwamitin Lafiya na Ƙasa, 1997.
10. Nederlandse Vereniging voor Arbeids-en Bedrijfsgeneeskunde (Ƙungiyar Magungunan Ma'aikata ta Dutch, NVAB). Handelen van de bedrijfsarts bij werknemers sun hadu da lage-rugklachten. Richtlijnen voor Bedrijfsartsen. [Jagorancin Yaren mutanen Holland don kula da likitocin ma'aikata na ma'aikata da ƙananan ciwon baya]. Afrilu 1999.
11. Carter JT, Birell LN. Jagororin kiwon lafiya na sana'a don kula da ƙananan ciwon baya a wurin aiki London: Makarantar Magungunan Ma'aikata, 2000 (www.facoccmed.ac.uk).
12. Jagororin kiwon lafiya na sana'a don kula da ƙananan ciwon baya a takardar aiki don masu aiki. London: Makarantar Magungunan Ma'aikata, 2000 (www.facoccmed.ac.uk).
13. Waddell G, Burton AK. Jagororin kiwon lafiya na sana'a don kula da ƙananan ciwon baya a aikin bita na shaida. Shagal Med 2001;51:124–35.
14. Roland M, da dai sauransu. Littafin baya. Norwich: Ofishin Kayan Aiki, 1996.
15. ICSI. Jagorar kula da lafiya. Babban ciwon baya. Cibiyar Haɗin Kan Tsarin Clinical, 1998 (www.icsi.org/guide/).
16. Kazimirski JC. Takaitacciyar manufofin CMA: Matsayin likitan wajen taimaka wa marasa lafiya su koma bakin aiki bayan rashin lafiya ko rauni. CMAJ 1997;156:680A�680C.
17. Yamamoto S. Sharuɗɗa akan rigakafin wurin aiki na ƙananan ciwon baya. Sanarwa ofishin ma'auni na ma'aikata, No. 57. Lafiyar masana'antu 1997;35:143�72.
18. SHIGA. Les Lombalgies da kuma masu sana'a: menene ainihin rigakafi da rigakafin? [Ƙananan ciwon baya a wurin aiki: abubuwan haɗari da rigakafin]. Paris: les editions INSERM, Littafin Littafi Mai Tsarki ya gane a la demande de la CANAM, 2000.
19. Lindstro?m I, Ohlund C, Eek C, et al. Tasirin ayyukan da aka ƙididdige akan marasa lafiya tare da ƙananan ƙananan ciwon baya: wani binciken da aka ba da izini na asibiti tare da yanayin yanayin aiki mai aiki. Maganin Jiki 1992;72:279�93.
20. Karjalainen K, Malmivaara A, van Tulder M, et al. Multidisciplinary biopsychosocial rehabilitation don ƙananan ciwon baya a cikin tsofaffi masu aiki: nazari na yau da kullum a cikin tsarin Cochrane Collaboration Back Review Group. Kashin baya 2001;26:262�9.
21. Stal JB, Hlobil H, van Tulder MW, et al. Komawa zuwa aikin aiki don ƙananan ciwon baya: nazarin bayanin abubuwan da ke ciki da ra'ayoyin hanyoyin aiki. Wasanni Med 2002;32:251�67.
22. Hoogendoorn WE, van Poppel MN, Bongers PM, et al. Nauyin jiki a lokacin aiki da lokacin hutu kamar abubuwan haɗari ga ciwon baya. Scand J Work Muhalli Lafiya 1999;25:387�403.
23. Loisel P, Gosselin L, Durand P, et al. Ƙididdigar yawan jama'a, gwajin gwaji na asibiti akan ciwon baya. Kashin baya 1997;22:2911�18.
24. Loisel P, Gosselin L, Durand P, et al. Aiwatar da shirin ergonomics na haɗin gwiwa a cikin gyaran ma'aikatan da ke fama da ciwon baya na subacute. Appl Ergon 2001;32:53–60.
25. Frank J, Sinclair S, Hogg-Johnson S, et al. Hana nakasa daga ƙananan ciwon baya na aiki. Sabbin shaidu suna ba da sabon bege idan za mu iya sanya duk 'yan wasan gaba. CMAJ 1998;158:1625�31.